Here’s a bold statement: the Predator franchise has survived decades of hits and misses, yet fans still can’t agree on which sequel or prequel truly reigns supreme. But here’s where it gets controversial: while some entries are celebrated as cult classics, others are downright divisive—and the reasons why might surprise you. Predator: Badlands just hit theaters this weekend, and it’s already on track to shatter franchise records, proving that this series is far from extinct. But let’s rewind for a moment. Like the Alien franchise, Predator films have never been box office titans, yet they’ve managed to stay relevant, drawing fans back generation after generation.
Take Predator 2, for example. Initially overlooked, it’s now hailed as a cult favorite—a testament to how time can transform a film’s legacy. (And yes, we’re still obsessed with it here at JoBlo.) And this is the part most people miss: even the most successful entries, like the Alien vs. Predator films, haven’t aged gracefully. The first AvP was a financial hit and remains the highest-grossing Predator movie, but it’s widely considered a letdown today. Its sequel, Alien vs. Predator: Requiem, somehow managed to be even worse—a baffling feat after the first one’s theatrical run.
Even the more polished follow-ups, like Predators, struggled to resonate with mainstream audiences, though they’ve carved out dedicated fanbases. Personally, one of my biggest letdowns as a critic was The Predator (2018). Shane Black’s return to the franchise was hyped as a triumphant comeback, but it ended up feeling like a chaotic mess.
Thankfully, the series has found its footing again under Dan Trachtenberg, who’s delivered three solid entries: Prey, Predator: Killer (or Killers), and now Predator: Badlands. But the burning question remains: Which Predator sequel or prequel is the best? We want to hear from you! Vote in our poll below, and while you’re at it, check out our full Predator Movies Ranked list.
Controversial question: Is Predator 2 truly a classic, or is its cult status overrated? And does Prey deserve more credit for revitalizing the franchise? Let us know in the comments—we’re ready for a heated debate!
